Ontario Regional Chief Stan Beardy has called for an immediate blockade of logging operations if the Ontario government’s plan to allow clear-cutting of mature trees within the Grassy Narrows First Nation territory goes forward.
Grassy Narrows Blockade to Resume if Logging Operation Starts
Gale Courey Toensing
Assembly of First Nations Ontario Regional Chief Stan Beardy has called for an immediate blockade of logging operations if the Ontario government’s plan to allow clear-cutting of mature trees within the Grassy Narrows First Nation territory goes forward.
“At the end of the day, if we’re forced to take direct action that’s what will happen,” Beardy told Indian Country Today Media Network. Beardy represents the chiefs of the 133 First Nations in the province of Ontario.
Grassy Narrows First Nation is known for holding the longest-running indigenous logging blockade in Canada and has spent nearly 15 years in court fighting the Ontario government’s decision to issue a license for clear-cutting operations in Keewatin, part of the Nation’s treaty-protected territory. In 2011 Ontario Superior Court ruled that the province cannot authorize timber and logging if the operations infringe on federal treaty promises protecting aboriginal rights to traditional hunting and trapping. This ruling has been appealed by Ontario and is expected to be heard at the Supreme Court of Canada on May 15, 2014.
RELATED:Grassy Narrows Anti-Logging Blockade Marks Ten-Year Anniversary
“The blockade was put on hold because we were under the impression that with the lawsuit pending, all [logging] activities had been put on hold, but unfortunately it looks like that’s not happening,” Beardy said.
Despite the Superior Court ruling, in December Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynn unilaterally approved a forest management to further clear-cut mature trees with the Grassy Narrows First Nation territory without community consultation or consent.
“The duty to consult” with First Nations on issues and projects that affect them and their lands is a legal requirement in Canada, “but they ignore the Constitution and legislation to consult with the legal holder of traditional lands,” Beardy said. “So if the logging starts up again, so will the blockage. Unfortunately, it seems to be the only way they’ll pay attention to us. We tried the political process, we tried having a conversation with them.’’
Members of the beleaguered Grassy Narrows First Nation say the Ontario government’s logging plans over the years have adversely affected forests in their community and worsened the mercury poisoning issues their citizens have been grappling with for decades.
RELATED:AFN Demands Answers in Grassy Narrows Mercury Poisoning
Between 1962 and 1970, Dryden Chemicals Inc., a paper mill, dumped 20,000 pounds of mercury into the Wabigoon River with the permission of the Province of Ontario. A recent Japanese study translated into English in June 2012 revealed that the mercury poisoning is still adversely affecting the health of Grassy Narrows people 50 years after the contamination of their river began. Dr. Masazumi Harada, the Japanese scientist who conducted the study, indicated that 79 percent of the people he tested in 2002 and 2004 had or may have had Minimata disease. This chronic neurological condition has affected three generations of Grassy Narrows people.
RELATED:Mercury Poisoning Five Decades Later for Grassy Narrows and White Dog First Nations
Grassy Narrows First Nation Chief Simon Fobister expressed his concerns in a December 23 news release following Wynne’s approval of Ontario's forest management plan, which would take effect in 2014.
"Premier Wynne, it is within your power to ensure that the mistakes of the past are not repeated at the expense of another generation of Grassy Narrows children," Fobister said. "I call on you to intervene to repeal this hurtful plan and to ensure that never again will Ontario attempt to force decisions on our people and our lands."
The province's new logging plan would clear-cut much of the remaining mature forest on Grassy Narrows territory. The tree removal not only worsens the effects of mercury poisoning but also threatens the existence of First Nations people culturally, Beardy said.
Clear-cutting violates First Nations treaty rights and the constitutionally protected rights to hunt, fish and trap because it destroys the environment and the animal and fish habitats and the wildlife itself that provides sustenance to the people, Beardy said.
“When First Nations people in Canada look at the [land taken], the residential schools, and now this that has happened to us, we consider it cultural genocide and that’s the message we’re taking to the inter national level [at the United Nations] to say that our rights as first Nations people of our not respected in Canada,” he said.
Fobister said his community has requested a meeting with Ontario Minister of Natural Resources David Orazietti in an effort to reach an understanding on how to move forward.
Although Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s government endorsed the U.N. Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples in 2010, “they consider it an aspirational document, a document with beautiful words,” said Beardy. “We’re pushing very hard to get Canada to adhere to the principle of ‘free prior and informed consent.’ ”
Kenora Daily Miner and News
Grassy Narrows chief meets with ministers
Friday January 31, 2014
By Brendan Harris
Local chiefs are returning from the provincial legislature. Grassy Narrows Chief Simon Fobister was joined by Treaty Three Grand Chief Warren White and Ontario Regional Chief Stan Beardy to meet with ministers to discuss logging near Grassy Narrows. They met with Natural Resources Minister David Orazietti and Aboriginal Affairs Minister David Zimmer. Fobister said they were hoping to address the concerns of the community, regarding treaty rights and possible mercury contamination related to clearcut logging.
"The reason why we are objecting to the Forest Management Plan is that they didn't do proper consultation accommodations. Our values were not included in the Forest Management Plan and our treaty and Aboriginal rights were being compromised," he said.
The First Nation has been expressing their concerns over logging for many years, with a blockade at Slant Lake in place for more than a decade and an upcoming date at the Supreme Court. While the concerns have been ongoing, Fobister said he believes the ministers were very receptive to their concerns.
"The ministers understood our position and I think that they agreed that our statements and our position were reasonable and they don't want a forestry management plan that compromises our rights," he said.
Fobister says he feels the meetings went well, and believes the meetings may help them make their case to stop clearcut logging in the Whiskey Jack Forest.
"We're reasonable people and our community is going to be impacted by any clearcut logging. We made our position very clear to the ministers and they seem to respect that. Hopefully they'll come up with a positive response and there won't be any clearcut logging in our territory," he said.
Fobister says they're hoping to hear back from the ministers before the Forest Management Plan comes into effect on April 1.